Comparative performance assessment of flat plate and evacuated tube collectors for domestic water heating systems in Kerman, Iran

Document Type : Research Paper


Mechanical Engineering Department, Engineering Faculty, Higher Education Complex of Bam, Bam, Iran


This study represents a year-round energy performance of two solar water heating (SWH) systems with a 4m2 flat plate collector (FPC) and an evacuated tube collector (ETC) operating under the same weather conditions. The energy performance of the two considered systems was compared on a monthly and yearly basis. The obtained results showed that for an annual total solar insolation of 2056kW.h.m-2, a total of 3577kW.h.y-1 and 4201kW.h.y-1 of heat energy were collected by 4m2 FPC and, ETC systems, respectively. The annual average energy efficiency by the FPC system was 43%, while its annual solar fraction was 50%. The ETC system had 51% energy efficiency with 58% solar fraction. The economic analysis showed that both solar water heating systems are not economically viable under prevailing costs in Iran. Furthermore, according to the obtained results, the FPCs are more favorable than the ETCs due to its economic analysis and energy performance. These results provide useful information for households and policymakers.


[1] Dincer I., Environmental impacts of energy, Energy policy (2017) 27: 845-854.
[2] Derakhshan S., Moghimi M., Motawej J., Development of a mathematical model to design an offshore wind and wave hybrid energy system, Energy Equipment Systems (2018) 6: 181-200.
[3] Sadeghi H., Alimardani R., Khanali M., Omidi A., Analysis of prediction models for wind energy characteristics, Case study: Karaj, Iran, Energy Equipment Systems (2018) 6: 27-37.
[4] Behzadi A., Gholamian E., Houshfar E., Ashjaee M., Habibollahzade A., Thermoeconomic analysis of a hybrid PVT solar system integrated with double effect absorption chiller for cooling/hydrogen production, Energy Equipment Systems (2018) 6: 413-425.
[5] Ghasemkhani A., Farahat S., Naserian M. M., The development and assessment of solar-driven Tri-generation system energy and optimization of criteria comparison, Energy Equipment Systems (2018) 6: 367-379.
[6] Habibollahzade A., Houshfar E., Ashjaee M. , Gholamian E., Behzadi A., Enhanced performance and reduced payback period of a low grade geothermal-based ORC through employing two TEGs, Energy Equipment Systems (2019) 7: 23-39.
[7] Ataei A., Safari F., Choi J. K., Thermodynamic performance analysis of different organic Rankine cycles to generate power from renewable energy resources, Am. J. Renew. Sustain. Energy (2015) 2: 31-38.
[8] Safari F., Tavasoli A., Ataei A., Gasification of Iranian walnut shell as a bio-renewable resource for hydrogen-rich gas production using supercritical water technology, International Journal of Industrial Chemistry (2017) 8: 29-36.
[9] Safari F., Dincer I., Assessment and optimization of an integrated wind power system for hydrogen and methane production, Energy Conversion Management (2018) 177: 693-703.
[10] Safari F., Dincer I., Development and analysis of a novel biomass-based integrated system for multigeneration with hydrogen production, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy (2019) 44: 3511-3526.
[11] Safari F., Ataei A., Thermal and electrical analysis of a linear parabolic CPVT system, Adv. Energy Res (2015) 3: 221-233.
[12] L. Ayompe L., A. Duffy A., Mc Keever M., Conlon M., McCormack S., Comparative field performance study of flat plate and heat pipe evacuated tube collectors (ETCs) for domestic water heating systems in a temperate climate, Energy (2011) 36: 3370-3378.
[13] Azad E., Experimental analysis of thermal performance of solar collectors with different numbers of heat pipes versus a flow-through solar collector, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews (2018) 82: 4320-4325.
[14] Colangelo G., Favale E., Miglietta P., de Risi A., Innovation in flat solar thermal collectors: A review of the last ten years experimental results, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews (2016) 57: 1141-1159.
[15] Pandey K. M., Chaurasiya R., A review on analysis and development of solar flat plate collector, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews (2017) 67: 641-650.
[16] Lamnatou C., Notton G., Chemisana D., Cristofari C., The environmental performance of a building-integrated solar thermal collector, based on multiple approaches and life-cycle impact assessment methodologies, Building and Environment (2015) 87: 45-58.
[17] Zambolin E., Del Col D., Experimental analysis of thermal performance of flat plate and evacuated tube solar collectors in stationary standard and daily conditions, Solar Energy (2010) 84: 1382-1396.
[18] Allen S., Hammond G., Harajli H., McManus M., Winnett A, Integrated appraisal of a solar hot water system, Energy (2010) 35: 1351-1362.
[19] Chow T., Fong K., Chan A., Lin Z., Potential application of a centralized solar water-heating system for a high-rise residential building in Hong Kong, Applied Energy (2006) 83: 42-54.
[20] Hang Y., Qu M., Zhao F., Economic and environmental life cycle analysis of solar hot water systems in the United States, Energy and Buildings (2012) 45: 181-188.
[21] Shirinbakhsh M., Mirkhani N., Sajadi B., Optimization of the PCM-integrated solar domestic hot water system under different thermal stratification conditions, Energy Equipment Systems (2016) 4: 271-279.
[22] Hajabdollahi Z., Hajabdollahi H., Thermo-economic modeling and multi-objective optimization of solar water heater using flat plate collectors, Solar Energy (2017) 155: 191-202.
[23] Harmim A., Boukar M., Amar M., Haida A., Simulation and experimentation of an integrated collector storage solar water heater designed for integration into building facade, Energy (2019) 166: 59-71.
[24] Kalogirou S., Thermal performance, economic and environmental life cycle analysis of thermosiphon solar water heaters, Solar Energy (2009) 83: 39-48.
[25] Ramedani Z., Omid M., Keyhani A., Feasibility and project viability analyses for installing SWH systems in greenhouses of Alborz province of Iran using RESTScreen, Electronic Journal of Environmental, Agricultural Food Chemistry (2012) 11: 565-577.
[26] Mostafaeipour A., Zarezade M., Goudarzi H., Rezaei-Shouroki M., Qolipour M., Investigating the factors on using the solar water heaters for dry arid regions: A case study, Renewable Sustainable Energy Reviews (2017) 78: 157-166.
[27] Kalogirou S. A., Solar energy engineering: processes and systems (2013), Academic Press.