Effect of grid resolution on NACA0012 self-noise prediction by large eddy simulation


Department of Aerospace Engineering, Amirkabir University of Technology, No. 350, Hafez Ave, Tehran 159163-4311, Iran



Airfoil self-noise is one of the dominant sources of airframe noises which causes limitations in many applications such as wind turbines. This paper investigates and quantifies the sensitivity of airfoil self-noise prediction to the grid resolution using large eddy simulation. Three-dimensional incompressible fluid flow around a NACA0012 airfoil at zero angle of attack with a chord-based Reynolds number of 6.4×105 is numerically analyzed in this paper. Far-field noise is predicted by Ffowcs-Williams & Hawkings model using the results of large eddy simulation. Three different grid sizes are used to investigate the effect of grid resolution on the accuracy of self-noise prediction. Results are compared with the experimental data of wind tunnel tests and noise measurements with microphones. Although the aerodynamic properties are calculated accurately in all grids, the grid resolution over the surface has a significant effect on the accuracy of the noise prediction. This effect of grid resolution is quantified in this paper. By the increase of grid points in the spanwise and streamwise directions on the surface, numerical noise prediction has approached the experimental data. The difference with the experimental data decreases from 20 dB to 3 dB in some frequencies. In addition, having doubled the number of surface grid points in both directions the average percentage of difference with the experimental data decreases from 5% to 2%.


[1] Winkler, J., et al., Trailing-edge broadband noise prediction of an airfoil with boundary-layer tripping. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2020. 482.
[2] Mackowski, T.H.C., Wind Turbine Trailing Edge Noise: Mitigation of Normal Amplitude Modulation by Individual Blade. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2021. 458.
[3] Chen, W., et al., On trailing edge noise from propellers with interactions to shear layers. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2021. 495.
[4] Jia, Z. and S. Lee, Aerodynamically induced noise of a lift-offset coaxial rotor with pitch attitude in high-speed forward flight. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2021. 491.
[5] De Gennaro, M., et al., Semi-Empirical Modelling of Broadband Noise for Aerofoils. 2011. p. 1498-1502.
[6] Brooks, T., F, D. Pope, S, and M. Marcolini, A,, Airfoil Self-Noise and Prediction. 1989, NASA 1218.
[7] Lighthill, M.J., On sound generated aerodynamically .I. General theory. Proc. Roy. Soc. A, 1952. 211: p. 564-587.
[8] Williams, F. and D.L. Hawkins, Sound Generation by Turbulence and Surfaces in Arbitrary Motion. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, 1969. 264(No. A 1151): p. 321-342.
[9] Lilly, G., On the Noise from Jets. AGARD CP-131, 1974: p. 13.1–13.10.
[10] Winkler, J., S. Moreau, and T. Carolus. Airfoil Trailing Edge Noise Prediction from Large-Eddy Simulation: Influence of Grid Resolution and Noise Model Formulation. in 16th AIAA/CEAS Aeroacoustics Conference. 2010.
[11] Arakawa, C., et al., Numerical approach for noise reduction of wind turbine blade tip with earth simulator. J. Earth Simul., 2005. 2(3): p. 11-33.
[12] Wang, M. and P. Moin, Computation of trailing-edge flow and noise using large-eddy simulation. AIAA Journal, 38(12), 2000: p. 2201–2209.
[13] Wasala, S., H,, et al., Aeroacoustic noise prediction for wind turbines using Large Eddy Simulation. J. Wind Eng. Ind. Aerodyn. 145, 2015: p. 17-29.
[14] Large-Eddy Simulation and Trailing-Edge Noise Prediction of an Airfoil with Boundary-Layer Tripping. in 15th AIAA/CEAS Aeroacoustics Conference. 2009.
[15] Wolf, W.R. and S.K. Lele, Trailing-Edge Noise Predictions Using Compressible Large-Eddy Simulation and Acoustic Analogy. AIAA Journal, 2012. 50(11): p. 2423-2434.
[16] Chen, N., et al., Effects and mechanisms of LES and DDES method on airfoil self-noise prediction at low to moderate Reynolds numbers. AIP Advances, 2021. 11(2).
[17] David P. Lockard, M.M.C.a.P.G.B., Grid Sensitivity Study for Slat Noise Simulations, in 20th AIAA/CEAS Aeroacoustics Conference. 2014 Atlanta, GA.
[18] Ueno, Y. and A. Ochi, Airframe Noise Prediction Using Navier-Stokes Code with Cartesian and Boundary-fitted Layer Meshes, in 25th AIAA/CEAS Aeroacoustics Conference. 2019.
[19] Yin, Y., Y. Shi, and W. Song, Mesh Study for Airfoil Trailing Edge Noise Predictions Using RANS CFD, in Aiaa Aviation 2020 Forum. 2020.
[20] Breuer, M., Boundary Conditions for LES, in Large-Eddy Simulation for Acoustics. 2007, Cambrifge University Press. p. 201–215.
[21] Hinze, J.O., Turbulence. 1975, New York: McGraw-Hill Publishing Co.
[22] Smagorinsky, J., General Circulation Experiments with the Primitive Equations.
Monthly Weather Review, 1963: p. 99-164.
[23] Germano, M., et al., A dynamic subgrid-scale eddy viscosity model. Phys. Fluids A: Fluid Dyn., 1989-1993: p. 1760-1765.
[24] Lilly, D.K., A Proposed Modification of the Germano Subgrid-Scale Closure Model. Physics of Fluids, 1992. 4: p. 633-635.
[25] ANSYS, I., ANSYS Fluent Theory Guide. Canonsburg.
[26] Lighthill, M.J., Sound generated aerodynamically. II. Turbulence as a source of sound. Proc. Roy. Soc. A, 1954. 222: p. 1-32.
[27] Lighthill, M.J., Jet Noise. AGARD Report, 1963: p. 448.
[28] Kianoosh, Y. and A. Razeghi. Determination of the Critical Reynolds Number for Flow over Symmetric NACA Airfoils. in AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting. 2018. Kissimmee, Florida.
[29] Gregory, N. and C. O'Reilly, L,, Low-Speed Aerodynamic Characteristics of NACA0012 Aerofoil Section, Including the Effects of Upper-Surface Roughness Simulating Hoar Frost. 1970, Aeronautical Research Council Reports and Memoranda.