Economic assessment of solar-based hydrogen for methanol production

Authors

Sustainable Energy Research Group (SERG), School of Mechanical Engineering, Iran University of Science and Technology, Tehran, Iran

10.22059/ees.2020.44753

Abstract

The climate change crisis has urged societies to take action for mitigating greenhouse gas emissions. Carbon neutral fuel is one of the proposed solutions to achieve this goal. Carbon neutral fuel is the product of captured CO2 with different methods such as direct air capture, sea water-absorbent, and power plant chimneys, and reformed through reactions with hydrogen under high temperatures and pressures. Methane, Methanol, E-diesel and Dimethyl Ether are some fuels that can be made through these processes. With this renewable fossil fuel, there will be no need for building new infrastructures, and it saves tons of money and mitigates greenhouse gas emissions resulting in higher GDP and life quality in the long term. Since there must be no added CO2 emissions within the whole process of carbon-neutral fuel production, to fulfill carbon neutrality, the hydrogen component should be produced from renewable energy sources like solar, wind or geothermal. This paper presents an economic assessment of the solar-based hydrogen for green methanol production. The results show that the levelized cost of solar-based hydrogen is dramatically higher than fossil-based hydrogen due to lack of investments in the renewable energy section in Iran. With a solar-based hydrogen price of $28.1/kg, green methanol price is evaluated $19159/mt.

Keywords


[1] Morales-Acevedo, A. (2014). Forecasting Future Energy Demand: Electrical Energy in Mexico as an Example Case. Energy Procedia. 57. 782-790.

[2] Moslener, U., McCrone, A., d'Estais, F., Grüning, C., Louw, A., Boyle, R., Strahan, D., Collins, B., Stopforth, K. (2017). Global Trends in Renewable Energy Investment 2017.

[3] Abas Kalair, N., Kalair, A., Khan, N. (2015). Review of Fossil Fuels and Future Energy Technologies. Futures. 69. 31-49.

[4] Gudarzi, Y., B., Varmazyari, S., Moshtaridoust. (2012). Energy Consumption in Iran: Past Trends and Future Directions. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences. 62. 12–17.

[5] Sternberg, A., Jens, Ch., Bardow, A. (2017). Life cycle assessment of CO2-based C1-chemicals. Green Chemistry. 19. 2244-2259.

[6] El-Shafie, M., Kambara, Sh., Hayakawa, Y., (2019). Hydrogen Production Technologies Overview. Journal of Power and Energy Engineering. 7. 107-154

[7] Boudries, R., (2016). Techno-economic Assessment of Solar-based hydrogen Production Using CPV-electrolysis Systems. Energy Procedia. 93. 96-101.

[8] Burhan, M., Oh, S.J., Chua, K.J.E., Kim Choon, Ng, (2016). Solar to hydrogen: Compact and cost effective CPV field for rooftop operation and hydrogen production. Applied Energy. 194. 255-266.

[9] Behzadi, A., Gholamian, E., Houshfar, E., Ashjaee, E., Habibollahzade, A., (2018). Thermoeconomic analysis of a hybrid PVT solar system integrated with double effect absorption chiller for cooling/hydrogen production. Energy Equipment and Systems. 6. 413-427.

[10] Kasiri, S., Momen, M., Behbahaninia, A., (2017). Economic optimization of solar systems in uncertain conditions using the Monte Carlo method. Energy Equipment and Systems. 5. 313-323.

[11] Ghasemkhani, A., Farahat, S., Naserian, M. M. (2018). The development and assessment of solar-driven tri-generation system energy and optimization of criteria comparison. Energy Equipment and Systems. 6. 367-379.

[12] Karapekmez, A., Dincer, I., (2018). Thermodynamic analysis of a novel solar and geothermal based combined energy system for hydrogen production. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. 45. 5608-5628.

[13] Bhandari, R., Trudewind, C., Zapp, P., (2013). Life cycle assessment of hydrogen production via electrolysis - A review. Journal of Cleaner Production. 85. 151-163.

[14] Symes, M., Cronin, L., (2013). Decoupling hydrogen and oxygen evolution during electrolytic water splitting using an electron-coupled-proton buffer. Nature chemistry. 5. 403-409.

[15] Fasihi, M., Efimova, O., (2019). Techno-economic assessment of CO2 direct air capture plants. Journal of Cleaner Production. 224. 957-980.

[16] Berstad, D., Anantharaman, R., Nekså, P., (2013). Low-temperature CO2 capture technologies – _Applications and potential. International Journal of Refrigeration. 36. 1403–1416.

[17] Raza, A., Gholami, R., Rezaee, R., Rasouli, V., Rabiei, M., (2018). Significant Aspects of Carbon Capture and Storage - A Review. Petroleum. 5. 335-340.

[18] Lawal, A., Wang, M., Stephenson, P., Obi, O. (2012). Demonstrating full-scale post-combustion CO2 capture for coal-fired power plants through dynamic modelling and simulation. Fuel. 101. 115-128.

 [19] Rifka, T., Morozyuk, T., (2019). Carbon capture and storage using low-temperature post-combustion technologies. Energy Sources, Part A: Recovery, Utilization, and Environmental Effects. 1-10.

[20] Liang, Zh., Rongwong, W., Liu, H., Fu, K., Gao, H., Cao, F., Zhang, R., Sema, T., Henni, A., Sumon, K., Nath, D., Gelowitz, D., Srisang, W., Saiwan, Ch., Benamor, A., Al-Marri, M., Shi, H., Supap, T., Chan, Ch., Tontiwachwuthikul, P., (2015). Recent progress and new developments in post-combustion carbon-capture technology with amine based solvents. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control. 40. 26-54.

[21] Jackson, S., Brodal, E.و (2019). Optimization of the Energy Consumption of a Carbon Capture and Sequestration Related Carbon Dioxide Compression Processes. Energies. 12. 1603-1616.

[22] Subramanian, A., Jordal, K., Anantharaman, R., Hagen, B., Roussanaly, S., (2017). A Comparison of Post-Combustion Capture Technologies for the NGCC. Energy Procedia. 114. 2631-2641.

[23] Jiang, L., Gonzalez Diaz, A., Ling-Chin, J., Roskilly, T., Smallbone, A., (2019). Post-combustion CO2 capture from a natural gas combined cycle power plant using activated carbon adsorption. Applied Energy. 245. 1-15.

[24] McNicol, B.D., Rand, D., Williams, K.R., (2001). Fuel cells for road transportation purposes - Yes or no?. Journal of Power Sources. 100. 47-59.

[25] Liu, W.Ch., Baek, J., Somorjai, G.,(2018). The Methanol Economy: Methane and Carbon Dioxide Conversion. Topics in Catalysis. 61. 530-541.

[26] Sheldon, D., (2017). Methanol Production ‐ _A Technical History. Johnson Matthey Technology Review. 61. 172-182.

[27] Zhen, X., Wang, Y., (2015). An overview of methanol as an internal combustion engine fuel. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 52. 477-493.

[28] Ham, L., Berg, H., Benneker, A., Simmelink, G., Timmer, J., Weerden, S., (2012). Hydrogenation of Carbon Dioxide for Methanol Production. Chemical Engineering Transactions. 29. 181-186.

[29] Matzen, M., Alhajji, M., Demirel, Y., (2015). Technoeconomics and Sustainability of Renewable Methanol and Ammonia Productions Using Wind Power-based Hydrogen. Journal of Advanced Chemical Engineering. 5. 128-140.

[30] Funk, J., (2001). Thermochemical hydrogen production: Past and present. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. 26. 185-190.

[31] Hosseini, S.E., Mahmoudzadeh Andwari, A., Wahid, M., Bagheri, Gh., (2013). A Review on Green Energy Potentials in Iran. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 27. 533-545.

[32] Carmo, M., Fritz, D., Mergel, J., Stolten, D., (2013). A comprehensive review on PEM electrolysis. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. 38. 4901-4934.

[33] Verma, S., (2015). A Review on Solar-based hydrogen Production Techniques. 4. 420-423.

[34] Belaissaoui, B., Favre, E., (2013). Membrane Separation Processes for Post-Combustion Carbon Dioxide Capture: State of the Art and Critical Overview. Oil, Gas Science and Technology. 69. 1005-1020.

[35] Jiang, Zh., Xiao, T., Kuznetsov, V., Edwards, P., (2010). Turning carbon dioxide into fuel. Philosophical transactions. Series A, Mathematical, physical, and engineering sciences. 368. 3343-3364.

[36] Agny, R., Takoudis, Ch., (2002). Synthesis of methanol from carbon monoxide and hydrogen over a copper-zinc oxide-alumina catalyst. Industrial, Engineering Chemistry Product Research and Development. 24. 50-55.

[37] Aničić, B., Trop, P., Goricanec, D. (2014). Comparison between two methods of methanol production from carbon dioxide. Energy. 77. 279-289.

[38] Martin, O., Martín, A., Mondelli, C., Mitchell, Sh., Segawa, T., Hauert, R., Drouilly, Ch., Curulla-Ferré, D., Pérez-Ramírez, J. (2016). Indium Oxide as a Superior Catalyst for Methanol Synthesis by CO2 Hydrogenation. Angewandte Chemie (International ed. in English). 55. 6261-6265.

[39] Viktorsson, L., Heinonen, J., Skulason, J., Unnthorsson, R., (2017). A Step towards the Hydrogen Economy—A Life Cycle Cost Analysis of A Hydrogen Refueling Station. Energies. 10. 1-15.

[40] Juaied, M., Whitmore, A., (2009). Realistic Cost of Carbon Capture.

[41] Rubin, E., Davison, J., Herzog, H., (2015). The cost of CO2 capture and storage. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control. 40. 378-400.

[42] Breton, M., Mirzapour, H., (2016). Welfare implication of reforming energy consumption subsidies. Energy Policy, 98. 232-240.

[43] Bakh, B., Ibrahim, Y., Alghoul, M., Hj Aziz, N., Fudholi, A., Sopian, K., (2014). Estimating the CO2 abatement cost: Substitute Price of Avoiding CO2 Emission (SPAE) by Renewable Energy׳s Feed in Tariff in selected countries. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 35. 205–210.

[44] Armesh, H., Salarzehi, H., Yaghoobi, N., Heydari, A., (2010). Causes of Inflation in the Iranian Economy. International Review of Business Research Papers. 6. 30-44.

[45] Financial Tribune, Rise in electricity and water tariffs in Iran, https://financialtribune.com/articles/energy/97278/rise-in-electricity-and-water-tariffs-in-iran, (accessed on April 06, 2019)

[47] Najafi, Gh., Ghobadian, B., Mamat, R., Yusaf, T.F., Azmi, W., (2015). Solar energy in Iran: Current state and outlook. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 49. 931-942.

[48] Christensen, A., Petrenko, Ch., (2017). CO2- based synthetic fuel: assessment of potential European capacity and environmental performance.

[49] Glenk, G., Reichelstein, S., (2019). Economics of converting renewable power to hydrogen. Nature Energy. 4. 216-222.